• العربية
  • فارسی
BrandBrand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo
INSIGHT

Ayatollah's death at 105 sparks ridicule over clerics' longevity

Hooman Abedi
Hooman Abedi

Iran International

Nov 18, 2026, 14:33 GMT+0
Hossein Vahid Khorasani, the senior Iranian Shiite cleric who died at 105.
Hossein Vahid Khorasani, the senior Iranian Shiite cleric who died at 105.

The death of Iranian Shiite cleric Hossein Vahid Khorasani at 105 has drawn ridicule and anger on social media, with Iranians questioning the longevity of prominent religious authorities and criticizing perceived clerical privilege following his death on Tuesday.

Responses to Iran International's post on X ranged from jokes about the ayatollah's advanced age to criticism of the religious establishment, with some contrasting his long life with their own health and economic difficulties.

“How did this bastard live to be 105? I'm 23 and there isn't a healthy part left in my body. I feel like I won't make it past 30,” one person wrote, adding laughing emojis.

The frustration comes against a backdrop of economic hardship, with some Iranians offering their organs for sale to pay debts and cover basic living expenses.

A recent Iran International examination of more than 600 online organ-sale advertisements found that roughly one-third offered multiple organs or body tissues, including kidneys, liver tissue and bone marrow. Some prospective sellers described struggling to afford housing, support their children or repay debts.

The longevity of senior clerics also stands in contrast to the lives of young Iranians killed during the Islamic Republic's January crackdown on nationwide protests. More than 36,500 people were killed by security forces on January 8 and 9, according to an Iran International

Vahid Khorasani died on November 17 after being hospitalized. Born in 1921, he spent decades teaching Islamic jurisprudence in the religious city of Qom.

Social media reactions target clerical privilege

Several comments portrayed Vahid Khorasani's long life as a reflection of the comfortable conditions associated with senior religious figures.

“From day one, all he did was live in idleness and comfort, without working, while benefiting from ordinary people's money,” one X account wrote.

Other responses used sarcasm to express resentment toward the clerical establishment.

“You finally managed it, Angel of Death! Congratulations!” read another post, accompanied by dancing emojis.

“The only useful thing the men of the seminary do is die, and they don't even do that on time,” another commenter wrote.

The announcement of a weeklong closure of the religious seminary also drew a celebratory response from one account, which welcomed both the cleric's death and the suspension of classes.

“Then why didn't your prayers to keep this mullah alive work?” another person asked.

One post joked that Vahid Khorasani had survived until the final moments of the Islamic Republic.

Why do some ayatollahs live so long?

Vahid Khorasani was among several prominent Shiite religious authorities who reached an advanced age.

Grand Ayatollah Lotfollah Safi Golpayegani died in 2022 at 102. Other senior Iranian clerics include Nasser Makarem Shirazi, 99, Hossein Nouri Hamedani, 101, and Ahmad Jannati, 99, who remains secretary of the Guardian Council, a powerful body that vets election candidates and reviews legislation.

Jannati, who has held the position since 1992, has become a frequent target of jokes about longevity in Iran. His advanced age and continued presence in power have repeatedly drawn ridicule on social media.

Iran's life expectancy at birth was approximately 78 years in 2024, according to World Bank figures. However, that figure does not represent the expected lifespan of people who have already reached old age.

While genetics and lifestyle can influence longevity, the advanced ages of prominent clerics have also drawn attention to their access to healthcare and relatively secure living conditions.

Senior Shiite clerics often spend decades within established religious institutions, where they are not required to undertake conventional employment and their standing can provide financial stability and institutional support.

For Iranians reacting to Vahid Khorasani's death at 105, his longevity highlighted the contrast between the lives of senior clerics and the hardships facing ordinary people, fueling criticism of the religious establishment and its perceived privileges.

  • Cash-strapped Iranians put multiple organs up for sale

    Cash-strapped Iranians put multiple organs up for sale

  • 97-Year-Old Iranian Cleric To Serve 32nd Year In Key Office

    97-Year-Old Iranian Cleric To Serve 32nd Year In Key Office

Most Viewed

Iran’s dams may have been built to support missile bases - NYT
1

Iran’s dams may have been built to support missile bases - NYT

2

US Army seeks 17 bunkers in Israel, Saudi, Lebanon amid Iran threats - report

3

UK PM warns Iran against attacks on journalists and military bases

4

Iran’s daily hardships find a voice in IRGC-linked media

5

Iranian girl's suspected honor killing raises questions over school's role

Banner

Spotlight

  • A cow's sit-in: why a comedy sketch struck a nerve in Iran

    A cow's sit-in: why a comedy sketch struck a nerve in Iran

  • Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely, experts say
    ANALYSIS

    Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely, experts say

  • Iran's wartime rallies turn against officials, fuel political feuds

    Iran's wartime rallies turn against officials, fuel political feuds

  • How Thai clerics in Iran were recruited to attack Israeli embassy in Bangkok
    EXCLUSIVE

    How Thai clerics in Iran were recruited to attack Israeli embassy in Bangkok

  • Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence
    ANALYSIS

    Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
  • Inside Qom Seminary, Iran’s political and spiritual powerhouse

    Inside Qom Seminary, Iran’s political and spiritual powerhouse

•
•
•

More Stories

Killing of Iranian schoolgirl sparks calls for legal reform

Nov 18, 2026, 11:54 GMT+0
100%
Sogand Sayyadi, a 16-year-old girl from Kermanshah, western Iran, whose death has sparked calls for legal reform and greater protection for children facing domestic violence.

The killing of a 16-year-old Iranian girl, allegedly by her father, has prompted lawyers and women's rights activists to demand tougher penalties for child killings and greater accountability from schools and child protection agencies in the western city of Kermanshah.

Sogand Sayyadi's death has drawn widespread criticism after accounts emerged that she had warned school officials she might not survive if sent home.

“Who was supposed to protect her and failed to do so?” one user wrote on X.

Sayyadi's father was arrested on charges including assault and provisionally murder, while the school principal was detained on suspicion of negligence, Kermanshah prosecutor Hamidreza Karimi said on November 17.

Sayyadi died from multiple injuries caused by a fall from a height, including fractures to her limbs, skull and teeth, provincial forensic medicine chief Behtash Khaniabad said.

Lawyers demand tougher penalties

Several lawyers called for changes to laws exempting fathers and paternal grandfathers from qisas, or retributive execution, for intentionally killing their children.

“Being a father creates responsibilities and obligations, not the right to take a child's life,” lawyer Saba Shams told Rokna news agency.

  • Iranian women killed by relatives after seeking divorce or refusing marriage

    Iranian women killed by relatives after seeking divorce or refusing marriage

Shams urged amendments to Iran's Islamic Penal Code, calling for stronger penalties for fathers who intentionally kill their children.

Under existing provisions, fathers and paternal grandfathers are exempt from qisas and may face prison sentences of three to 10 years when legal conditions are met.

The punishment is neither appropriate nor sufficient, lawyer Saleh Noghrehkar told Ensaf News, arguing that impunity encourages further violence.

School officials also face questions over their handling of Sayyadi's reported warnings.

“What are school officials supposed to do in such situations? Have they not been trained?” lawyer Fereshteh Tabanian wrote, sharing a statement attributed to Sayyadi that she would not return alive if sent home.

  • Over a dozen Iranian women and girls killed in 30 days, many by male relatives

    Over a dozen Iranian women and girls killed in 30 days, many by male relatives

The legal organization Dadban said Iranian child protection laws require schools to identify students at risk and notify relevant authorities. Officials could face criminal liability if they knowingly failed to protect Sayyadi, it said.

No report concerning threats against Sayyadi reached social emergency services, and school officials never contacted the agency, Kermanshah welfare chief Majid Darvishi told local media.

Medical emergency services also received no call to transport Sayyadi, whose body was apparently taken to a medical facility in a private vehicle, emergency services spokesperson Mojtaba Lashgari said.

Women's rights activists condemn lack of protection

“The issue is not just one father or one family; it is a culture that defines a woman's body as family property, her love as a crime, her opposition as dishonor and her silence as a virtue,” journalist and women's rights activist Shiva Ganji wrote on Instagram.

“They are condemned not for what they have done, but for what they are,” singer Mehdi Yarrahi wrote on X.

  • Young Iranian girl murdered by father in honor killing

    Young Iranian girl murdered by father in honor killing

Some users compared Sayyadi's death with the killing of teenager Romina Ashrafi by her father.

“Yesterday Romina was killed, and today Sogand; yet for years there has been no progress on a bill to protect women,” one user wrote.

“Violence sometimes begins very quietly with the words, 'Her father knows best,'” another wrote, calling for better teacher training.

Sociologist Mohammad Bagher Tajeddin criticized failures across families, schools and society.

“Uninformed families, uninformed and irresponsible principals and teachers, and an indifferent and irresponsible society all contribute to the occurrence of such tragedies,” he wrote in Ham-Mihan newspaper.

Legislation intended to protect women against violence remains unapproved after more than 15 years of disputes between Iranian authorities.

  • Iran withdraws violence against women law after hardliner revisions

    Iran withdraws violence against women law after hardliner revisions

At least 84 women and girls were killed in Iran between late March and October 13, including 12 minors, the Emtedad website reported on November 16. Eight victims were killed by fathers, brothers or other blood relatives.

The figures, compiled from media reports, may not reflect the full number of victims.

Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely, experts say

Nov 18, 2026, 11:20 GMT+0
•
Negar Mojtahedi
100%
A US Capitol Police officer patrols the east front of the US Capitol in Washington, US September 15, 2021.

Iran could carry out a radiological or chemical-weapons attack in the United States, but operational hurdles and retaliation risks make it unlikely, experts told Iran International following reports of plots targeting senior US officials.

The assessments followed a CNN report citing seven US officials who said intelligence indicated Iran was developing plans to potentially target senior Trump administration officials in Washington with a dirty bomb or chemical weapon.

"Dirty bomb is not typically what you would use to assassinate someone," said David Albright, a physicist and president of the Institute for Science and International Security.

Farzin Nadimi, a senior fellow at the Washington Institute specializing in Iran's military affairs, assessed the likelihood of an attack as "low to very low," citing operational difficulties and the prospect of US retaliation.

Two sources cited by CNN said the planning included specific locations and targets, although there was no evidence that Iranian leaders had decided to proceed. Officials differed over whether personnel were already in place.

  • Iran developing unconventional warheads for ballistic missiles, sources say

    Iran developing unconventional warheads for ballistic missiles, sources say

The White House said there were "no credible threats to the homeland" at the time. President Donald Trump said Tuesday that Washington was investigating the information and taking the possibility seriously.

Iran denied the allegations, while Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin described the planning as "aspirational."

Iran's chemical-weapons history

Iran's history of acquiring and transferring unconventional weapons provides grounds for taking the warnings seriously, Behnam Ben Taleblu, senior director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies' Iran Program, said.

"These are threats that do need to be taken seriously," Taleblu said. "Conversely, the intelligence leaks and the sources should also be scrutinized."

Taleblu cited Iran's past transfers of chemical weapons to Muammar Gaddafi's Libya.

US State Department compliance reports have identified Iran's failure to declare chemical-weapons transfers during the Libya-Chad war as a violation of the Chemical Weapons Convention.

  • Rights groups call for probe into alleged chemical use in Iran protests

    Rights groups call for probe into alleged chemical use in Iran protests

A 2019 report cited chemical-filled artillery projectiles and aerial bombs transferred to Libya, alongside chemical mortar rounds assessed to be of Iranian origin found in Iraq, as evidence supporting Washington's assessment that Iran had filled and possessed chemical weapons.

A subsequent report identified Iran's pursuit of pharmaceutical-based agents for offensive purposes as another compliance violation.

Despite that history, Taleblu did not regard the latest warnings as necessarily signaling a change in Iran's military doctrine.

"I think this is a lot more of the same," he said.

Would a dirty bomb be effective?

The alleged assassination objective raises questions about the choice of weapon, particularly whether a radiological device would be effective against individual targets.

A dirty bomb combines conventional explosives with radioactive material. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says its primary immediate danger generally comes from the explosion, although radioactive contamination can create additional health risks.

Such a device could force evacuations and spread fear, but would be less suited to killing a particular individual, Albright said.

"In terms of an assassination method, I wouldn't consider it very effective," he said.

Chemical agents could be more effective for targeting individuals, Albright argued, citing research published by his institute in 2024 identifying evidence of Iranian work on delivering pharmaceutical-based agents using drones.

Whether that work produced an operational capability or was connected to a specific US attack plan remained unclear.

"I think it's also important to keep in mind that the story said there was no imminent threat," Albright added.

Operational obstacles and retaliation risks

Beyond the choice of weapon, carrying out an attack would require access to materials, reliable personnel and the ability to evade US security measures.

Iranian intelligence services could potentially construct a crude radiological device if they obtained the necessary material inside the United States, Nadimi assessed.

"The likelihood I believe is low to very low, given the risks associated with such an action and the high possibility of retaliation," he said.

Questions about operational readiness also concerned Mark Fowler, a former CIA operations officer with extensive experience involving Iran, who questioned who was discussing the alleged attack and how far preparations had advanced.

"It's not clear to me that they actually have that in hand at this point," Fowler said, referring to the required materials.

CNN reported that Iranian communications suggested bomb-making materials were already inside the United States. Officials disputed the credibility of that information, although some considered it likely that materials had been positioned in advance.

Nadimi considered domestic acquisition theoretically possible, while Albright emphasized US accounting and security measures that make obtaining radioactive material more difficult.

A 2021 National Academies study identified vulnerabilities involving some civilian radioactive sources and warned that even relatively small radioactive releases could have lasting socioeconomic consequences.

The warnings could also strain US security resources even without an attack, Mike Pregent, a former intelligence officer who has testified before Congress about Iran's overseas terrorism networks, said.

"They've already got everybody spinning up on it," Pregent said.

  • FBI adds IRGC member accused in Bolton plot to most wanted terrorists list

    FBI adds IRGC member accused in Bolton plot to most wanted terrorists list

Any radiological or chemical-weapons attack could also harden American public opinion against the Islamic Republic and provoke severe retaliation, Nadimi said.

The reported consideration of such an operation, however, "does not show a decision is made to act," he added.

Iranian girl's suspected honor killing raises questions over school's role

Nov 17, 2026, 13:28 GMT+0
100%
Sogand Sayadi

The suspected honor killing of a 16-year-old Iranian schoolgirl has raised questions about her school's failure to protect her after she reportedly warned that her life was in danger, with authorities announcing the arrest of her father and school principal on Tuesday.

Sogand Sayyadi died after leaving school with her father in Kermanshah, western Iran, prompting calls from teachers' organizations and human rights groups for an investigation into the circumstances surrounding her death.

Her father was detained on suspicion of assault and provisionally murder, while the school principal was arrested on suspicion of negligence, the judiciary-affiliated Mizan news agency reported, citing provincial chief prosecutor Hamidreza Karimi.

Investigators are examining possible murder or suicide, with forensic examinations continuing to determine the cause of death and any criminal responsibility, Karimi said.

  • Over a dozen Iranian women and girls killed in 30 days, many by male relatives

    Over a dozen Iranian women and girls killed in 30 days, many by male relatives

Sayyadi had reportedly warned school officials that her life would be in danger if she returned home with her father. Her body was discovered the following morning in the courtyard of her residential building.

Photographs published from her funeral also showed her father standing among mourners during the funeral prayer.

Accounts of violence at school and home

Officials at the school summoned Sayadi's father, Kioumars Sayyadi, after learning about a matter involving her private life, the Hana Human Rights Organization reported Monday.

Accounts surrounding the case suggest the dispute concerned the teenager's romantic relationship with a boy, although the school principal denied that this prompted the decision to summon her father.

Sayyadi's father severely beat her in front of classmates and repeatedly struck her head against a wall outside the school, Hana reported, citing its sources.

The violence continued at home, where her father threw her from the building, according to the organization.

Other accounts suggest the teenager fell from the fifth floor of the building.

Kermanshah's education department offered a different account of her departure from school, saying her father had visited to collect her academic records and arrange her transfer to Gilan-e Gharb, a town in western Iran.

The two left school around 9 a.m., the department said.

  • Iranian women killed by relatives after seeking divorce or refusing marriage

    Iranian women killed by relatives after seeking divorce or refusing marriage

Sayyadi lived with her stepmother and faced family disagreements, while apparently being pressured to return to her hometown, Jahangir Aghaei, the department's public relations director, said.

Teachers question school's responsibility

The Coordinating Council of Iranian Teachers' Trade Associations accused school officials of disregarding Sayadi's warnings and demanded accountability from the Education Ministry in a statement Monday.

The council called for an end to interference in students' private lives, stronger child protection mechanisms and the removal of laws that shield perpetrators of family violence.

Hana also demanded an independent investigation into the death and the possible responsibility of school staff.

Under Article 301 of Iran's Islamic Penal Code, fathers and paternal grandfathers are exempt from qisas, or retaliatory execution, for killing their children.

Femicide figures highlight wider problem

At least 84 women and girls were killed in Iran between March 21 and October 13, including 12 girls under 18, according to figures compiled from cases documented in media coverage.

100%
Mourners gather for Sogand Sayyadi's funeral in western Iran.

In 75 cases, the perpetrators were known to the victims. Eight of the underage victims were killed by fathers, brothers or other blood relatives.

The figures reflect documented cases rather than the total number of killings.

Legislation intended to protect women against violence remains unapproved after more than 15 years of debate among Iranian government institutions.

Sayyadi's death has intensified scrutiny of the responsibilities of schools and state institutions to protect girls facing threats within their families, particularly when warnings of possible violence are raised before a death occurs.

Daily reports secret bread rationing in two Iranian provinces

Nov 17, 2026, 10:37 GMT+0
100%
File photo: People queue to buy bread outside a bakery in Iran.

Bread rationing has been introduced without public notice in two Iranian provinces, triggering queues and disputes at bakeries, the hardline daily Kayhan reported, as government officials confirmed a nationwide bread purchase management system on Tuesday, November 17.

Kayhan, published under the supervision of a representative of Iran's Supreme Leader, reported that the restrictions had been introduced in Khuzestan province in southwestern Iran and Zanjan province in the northwest without informing bakers or consumers in advance.

The measures prompted residents to rush to bakeries and led to verbal confrontations, the newspaper reported.

Under the system described by Kayhan, each person receives a monthly allocation equivalent to approximately eight kilograms of subsidized flour, priced at 23,000 rials ($0.009) per kilogram.

Purchases exceeding the allocation are charged at the commercial rate of 126,500 rials ($0.047), more than five times the subsidized price, with the additional payments transferred to government accounts, Kayhan reported.

The newspaper questioned why the measures had been introduced without informing bakers or consumers and accused “elements within the government” of contributing to “public anxiety” through simultaneous changes affecting bread, gasoline and electronic food vouchers.

Local media had previously reported restrictions in Shadegan, Andimeshk, Omidiyeh and Zeydun in Khuzestan province, where daily bread allocations were set at between two and 2.5 loaves per person.

Purchases exceeding those amounts were priced at 131,500 rials ($0.049), according to the local reports.

Officials confirm nationwide rollout, deny household restrictions

The bread purchase management system is being implemented across Iran, but ordinary households face no restrictions on their daily purchases, Omid Jahannejadian, director-general of Khuzestan's Grain and Commercial Services Department, told the official IRNA news agency on Tuesday.

The program is intended to regulate subsidized flour consumption, prevent potential misuse and identify purchases exceeding normal household needs, Jahannejadian said.

Consumption thresholds are calculated using purchasing data collected over the past two years, taking account of differences between urban and rural areas.

The system calculates allocations at the household level, with purchases by family members counted toward a combined household allowance, Jahannejadian added.

100%
File photo: A baker prepares traditional bread at a bakery in Iran.

In Zanjan province, Ali Eyvazi, director-general of the provincial Grain and Commercial Services Department, also confirmed that unusually large bread purchases would be charged at commercial rates.

Ordinary household purchases would not face higher prices, Eyvazi told IRNA.

The guidelines were issued on November 15, with the system subsequently updated at bakeries and flour mills.

Although the average monthly flour allocation per Iranian is approximately eight kilograms, applying an identical limit to every person without accounting for household circumstances and regional differences would be inaccurate, Eyvazi said.

The program was initially tested in Markazi province before authorities decided to expand its implementation to other provinces following an evaluation.

In a separate interview with the Mehr news agency, Eyvazi rejected descriptions of the measures as a two-tier bread pricing system, saying ordinary household consumption would remain unrestricted despite the introduction of purchasing thresholds.

Supermarkets must obtain bread from bakeries operating without government subsidies, while commercial purchases from subsidized bakeries must comply with the new rules, Eyvazi added.

Rising food costs put pressure on households

The introduction of bread purchase controls comes as Iranians face increasing difficulties affording basic food products.

Iran's minimum monthly base wage stands at about 166 million rials ($62), following a 60 percent increase in March. The cost of a basic monthly basket of goods for a working-class family had reached approximately 906 million rials ($337) by July, more than five times the minimum base wage, according to calculations cited by Iranian media.

Accounts sent to Iran International describe households turning to installment payments to purchase essential items, including bread, meat, chicken and eggs.

  • Inflation pushes Iranians to buy food in installments

    Inflation pushes Iranians to buy food in installments

In a video showing a bakery queue in Tehran, one resident described shortages alongside rising prices and shrinking loaf sizes.

"Bread has become scarce, and we have to stand in line to buy it. At the same time, the loaves have become smaller and more expensive. Can someone tell us how we are supposed to feed our children?" the resident said.

Other citizens have described reductions in flour allocations and changes in the taste and color of bread.

  • Flour shortages force bakeries to close across Iran

    Flour shortages force bakeries to close across Iran

Economic hardship is also affecting social relations as more households struggle to meet their basic needs, sociologist Hossein Ghazian told Iran International.

When survival becomes people's primary concern, competition increasingly replaces cooperation, potentially contributing to domestic violence, street confrontations and crime, Ghazian said.

The economic pressures can also contribute to depression, suicide, declining marriage and birth rates, and migration, reflecting diminishing confidence in the future, Ghazian added.

  • Food, medicine, hope: what Iran's economic crisis is costing its people

    Food, medicine, hope: what Iran's economic crisis is costing its people

The nationwide bread controls introduce new purchasing thresholds for a staple food even as officials insist that ordinary household consumption will remain unaffected.

Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence

Nov 17, 2026, 04:52 GMT+0
•
Negar Mojtahedi
100%
A mourner attends the funeral of a commander from Iraq's Kataib Hezbollah armed group who was killed in what they called a "Zionist attack" in the Syrian capital Damascus on Friday, during a funeral in Baghdad, Iraq September 22, 2024. REUTERS/Thaier Al-Sudani/File Photo Purchase Licensing Rights

Iraq’s attempt to reclaim a stronghold of Iran-backed militia could test Baghdad’s authority over armed factions while leaving much of Tehran’s influence over the country’s politics, security forces and economy intact, experts told Iran International.

Baghdad ordered troops on Monday to enter Jurf al-Sakher, south of the capital, following an investigation into suspected oil smuggling. The faction has been given until Friday to withdraw, according to a security source cited by AFP.

The move comes amid US pressure to rein in Iran-backed militias, but taking control of the town would not necessarily dismantle the political and financial networks that sustain their power.

“It’s going to be once again a theatrical show,” said Omar Mohammed, an Iraqi historian who documented life under Islamic State through his blog Mosul Eye.

Senior Iraqi officials told Reuters that Kataib Hezbollah had operated an oil-smuggling network for years, generating hundreds of millions of dollars since 2021. The US-designated terrorist organization, which has attacked American forces in the region, has long controlled Jurf al-Sakher, also known as Jurf al-Nasr, in Babil province south of Baghdad. Kataib Hezbollah denied the smuggling allegations, Anadolu reported.

Why Jurf al-Sakher matters

Mohammed described Jurf al-Sakher as a financial hub Iran has used to evade sanctions. He said the town’s location near roads linking Baghdad with Karbala and Anbar gives whoever controls it strategic leverage over the capital. He also pointed to the displacement of Sunni residents, whose prolonged exclusion has fueled sectarian tensions.

More than 100,000 people from Jurf al-Sakher and surrounding communities remain unable to return more than a decade after Iraqi forces retook the area from Islamic State in 2014, Shafaq News reported. Government committees have entered the area in recent months, but such visits have been unusual and required high-level security and political coordination, the outlet said.

Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi “ordered the armed forces to enter” Jurf al-Sakher, government spokesman Haidar al-Aboudi told the Iraqi News Agency, adding that “a deadline has been set for the armed faction to exit the area.” A security source told AFP the deadline was Friday.

Al-Aboudi said investigators found evidence of pipeline tampering. Nine security and oil officials were dismissed following the investigation, Reuters reported.

Sources told The New Arab that fighting between Iraqi forces and Iran-backed factions was possible. A senior Iraqi official told the outlet that the government had deployed armored vehicles to the town’s outskirts.

The militias’ reach beyond the town

David Patrikarakos, a special correspondent for the Daily Mail and author of Nuclear Iran: The Birth of an Atomic State, recalled seeing a separate line of commercial trucks at a checkpoint outside Mosul when he reported from Iraq a few years ago. His local contacts told him the truck drivers had to pay Iran-backed militias a levy to enter the city.

Patrikarakos welcomed Baghdad’s attempt to push back but said the government had limited room to maneuver. He pointed to the factions’ political wings and their role in the Popular Mobilization Forces, a state-funded security body that formally answers to the prime minister. Some factions, he said, retain their own weapons, separate chains of command and ties to Iran.

“I think maybe the Iranian-backed militias will allow them some cosmetic gains, but there’s no way that Iran is going to allow its footprint in Iraq to disappear,” he told Iran International.

Patrikarakos said Tehran sees Iraq as part of its strategic depth and that Iran-backed factions could make limited concessions while retaining much of their power. He said clashes were possible and questioned whether the Iraqi government could prevail in an armed confrontation.

Mohammed, whose recent memoir is Mosul Eye: A Scholar’s Clandestine War Against ISIS, said al-Zaidi’s reach was limited by how deeply the militias were embedded in Iraq’s economy and politics. He cited their access to US dollars and what he described as their grip on commerce in Mosul. In his view, taking Jurf al-Sakher would leave much of that influence intact.

Even if al-Zaidi is sincere, Mohammed said, his government lacks the political will and institutional capacity to rein in the Iran-backed factions. “Militias are still in control,” he said.

US pressure puts al-Zaidi to the test

Former US Ambassador John Craig called Baghdad’s move “about 10 years overdue.” He said Washington was putting significant pressure on al-Zaidi and that the prime minister appeared to understand that Iraq’s stability depended on reining in Iran-backed militias.

Craig questioned whether Iraqi forces had the training and resources to push back against factions that have had years to entrench themselves. He said some doubt al-Zaidi’s independence from the militias and see the order as an effort to satisfy Washington. The prime minister’s actions, Craig said, would show how serious he was.

Al Arabiya, citing unnamed sources, reported that al-Zaidi left a meeting of the ruling Shiite Coordination Framework after disagreements over Jurf al-Sakher.

An Iranian delegation arrived in Baghdad on Monday for talks aimed at defusing the standoff, Al Arabiya reported, citing sources. The delegation was expected to meet Iraqi officials, Shiite Coordination Framework leaders and armed factions to prevent a military confrontation.

Some Coordination Framework leaders proposed replacing Kataib Hezbollah fighters with Popular Mobilization Forces units affiliated with Iraq's religious shrines as a compromise, according to the report.

Mohammed said the troop order gave Baghdad something to show Washington. He argued that sustained pressure from the United States and Iraq’s neighbors could push the government toward more substantive action.

A lasting crackdown, he said, would require political will, a clear strategy and institutions capable of carrying it out.