• العربية
  • فارسی
Brand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo

Iran Wants To Stop Billions Of Dollars In Capital Flight

Iran International Newsroom
Aug 18, 2022, 19:35 GMT+1Updated: 17:33 GMT+1
A money changer in a Tehran street outside a more established forex business
A money changer in a Tehran street outside a more established forex business

Iran’s government will announce new regulations and act to stem the tide of large and sustained capital flight, the economy minister announced Thursday.

Iran continues to face oil export and international banking sanctions imposed by the United States and a considerable chunk of its foreign currency revenues are invested abroad by those who make money in the beleaguered economy.

Estimates range from 10-15 billion dollars of capital leaving Iran every year, while the country has been under various sanctions for more than 10 years since 2010. Its oil income dwindled from a $100 billion in 2009-2010 to less than $20 billion in 2019, derailing all development plans and creating huge budget deficits.

When the United States withdrew from the Iran nuclear deal in 2018 and re-imposed sanctions, some reports spoke of around $30 billion leaving the country during that year by people who lost confidence in the economy.

The Minister of Economy and Treasury Ehsan Khandouzi says the government and the Central Bank of Iran (CBI) will come up with solutions to reduce capital flight, although he has not explained how.

Iranian businesses and individuals use at least two methods to either take capital out or keep their earnings abroad.

Iranian economy minister Ehsan Khandouzi. FILE PHOTO
100%
Iranian economy minister Ehsan Khandouzi

The first pertains to those who have legitimate export or import businesses and receive government dollars at preferential rates, to buy raw materials abroad. There have been accusations that some of that money sent abroad to finance imports, is diverted to foreign bank accounts or invested in other countries. Another loophole is that exporters who are supposed to bring their earnings back do so only partially and keep the rest abroad.

Another way is simply buying dollars and other foreign currencies on the black market and sending it abroad through a very fast, flexible, reliable and cheap informal network of money changers – much like the famous ‘hawala’ system well known in West Asia. One could give a million dollars to a money changer in Tehran and for a fee the funds will be delivered to any foreign country.

Khandouzi told the local media that during the past Iranian calendar year, (March 2021-March 2022) the country’s capital account deficit reached $7.5 billion, a red flag indicating capital flight.

To put in perspective, if Iran would earn $40 billion from oil exports amid US sanctions and $10 billion left the country as fleeing capital, one could argue that foreign earnings were in fact 25 percent less.

It should also be noted that Iran attracts virtually no foreign capital or investments, due to uncertainties and instability generated by its tense foreign relations and the nuclear dispute with the West.

Some of the foreign currency leaving Iran is invested by individuals to buy homes, primarily in Turkey. According to official Turkish government figures, Iranians bought more than 10,000 residential units in 2021. If the average price of each unit was $150,000, Iranians spent $1.5 billion on housing investments in Turkey alone. They also buy homes in the United Arab Emirates, Europe, Canada and the United States.

Among these people many must be government officials or work closely with the government, given the fact that 80 percent of Iran’s economy is owned by the state, quasi-governmental entities and foundations controlled by the ruling elite.

Most Viewed

Iran diplomacy wobbles as factions compete to avoid looking soft on US
1
INSIGHT

Iran diplomacy wobbles as factions compete to avoid looking soft on US

2
VOICES FROM IRAN

Bread shortages, soaring prices strain households in Iran, residents say

3
ANALYSIS

The politics of pink: how Iran uses cuteness to rebrand violence

4

Scam messages seek crypto for ships’ safe passage through Hormuz, firm warns

5
EXCLUSIVE

Family told missing teen was alive, then received his body 60 days later

Banner
Banner

Spotlight

  • Diplomacy tolls at Hormuz as conflict returns to its doorstep
    OPINION

    Diplomacy tolls at Hormuz as conflict returns to its doorstep

  • Opposition to US talks grows in Tehran as ceasefire deadline nears
    INSIGHT

    Opposition to US talks grows in Tehran as ceasefire deadline nears

  • Tehran moderates see ‘no deal–no war’ limbo as worst outcome
    INSIGHT

    Tehran moderates see ‘no deal–no war’ limbo as worst outcome

  • The future has been switched off here
    TEHRAN INSIDER

    The future has been switched off here

  • Lights out, then gunfire: Witnesses recount Mashhad protest crackdown
    VOICES FROM IRAN

    Lights out, then gunfire: Witnesses recount Mashhad protest crackdown

  • Is Iran entering its Gorbachev moment?
    INSIGHT

    Is Iran entering its Gorbachev moment?

•
•
•

More Stories

Pompeo Joins Pressure Campaign To Block Iranian President’s Visit To UN

Aug 18, 2022, 15:46 GMT+1

Former secretary of state Mike Pompeo has joined the chorus of US officials who have called on the Biden administration not to allow Iran’s president to enter the US for the UN General Assembly. 

Pompeo, who was one of the main targets of a newly-revealed assassination campaigns by Iran, told the Washington Free Beacon that the Biden administration is setting a dangerous precedent by permitting Ebrahim Raisi -- who is on the US and European sanctions list -- into the US to attend UN ceremonies next month following his repeated threats against the US.

"We worked for four years to deny Iranian terrorists the freedom to put Americans at risk. This administration is allowing them to come to New York City while actively engaged in efforts to kill Americans on US soil. The Iranians just recently sponsored an attack that was almost successful in killing an American in that very city. We can do better," Pompeo said, referring to the Justice Department charges against a member of the Revolutionary Guard (IRGC) for an alleged plot to kill former national security advisor John Bolton and Pompeo.

Nikki Haley, the former ambassador to the United Nations during the Trump administration, also criticized the UN for providing a megaphone to the world’s top sponsor of terror. 

"This shows just how corrupt and broken the UN is. Even when Iranian terrorists try to assassinate our officials, on our soil, the UN welcomes them with open arms and lets them give a speech," she said. 

Earlier in the month, eight US Republican senators, including Tom Cotton, March Rubio, Joni Ernst and Ted Cruz, wrote to President Joe Biden asking him to deny the visa to Raisi.

Data Analysis Says Iranians May Have Lost Sensitivity To News On JCPOA

Aug 18, 2022, 14:35 GMT+1
•
Iran International Newsroom

Prolonged nuclear negotiations and its ebbs and flows have eroded Iranian social media users' sensitivity to the news about the talks, a new study has claimed.

According to Shargh daily in Tehran, a data analysis by Mohamad Rahbari indicates that numerous reports about the success or failure of negotiations have pushed social media users back and forth between hope and despair in the past 18 months. The report suggests that in recent weeks, despite more optimism surrounding the revival of the JCPOA, Iranian social media users have become less sensitive to news about the talks.

But the report does not cite figures from the past about the degree of interest in JCPOA to substantiate its claim of declining interest.

Iranian Twitter users posted some 22,000 tweets about the JCPOA from August 6-13. The data collected by Rahbari suggests that there was a rise in attention to the issue until Tuesday, August 9, followed by a decline. But as more optimistic reports started to come in, the number of tweets reached a peak of nearly 4,000 on August 13.

The report added that nonetheless, the JCPOA was not the top issue for Twitter users. A review of other political and economic reports during the week showed that a statement issued by former presidential candidate Mir Hossein Mousavi, which challenged Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei's authority, caught the most attention and the JCPOA was the second most important news. 

While there were 22,000 tweets about the JCPOA, the Mousavi story generated 31,000 posts, and the Rushdie attack 15,000.

A government-financed newspaper in Iran depicting Salam Rushdie as the Devil
100%
A government-financed newspaper in Iran depicting Salam Rushdie as the Devil on August 14

Meanwhile, although there were more tweets about the JCPOA than those about the assassination attempt on British author Salman Rushdie, the posts about Rushdie received more "likes" than those about the JCPOA.

Things, however, were different on Telegram channels where the news about the JCPOA attracted far more attention than the stories about Mousavi or Rushdie. Nonetheless, there were many more posts about the exchange rate of Iran’s currency, as the rial began to rise against the US dollar.

Here, the JCPOA was the subject of 53,000 posts, forex 95,000, with the rest below 20,000 each.

On the other hand, trends in Google searches which reflect people's preoccupations and questions more accurately, indicate that users showed the least degree of interest to the JCPOA and its revival. In other words, there were more searches about Salman Rushdie (yellow graph), subsidies (purple), Mousavi (red), and Forex and gold (green) than about the JCPOA and its revival (blue) [Figure 4]. This shows that a large number of Iranians who use Google search, were far less sensitive about the JCPOA than about other matters.

Google search results in Persian for five news topis
100%
Google search results in Persian for five news topis

The research observed that most of the tweets about the JCPOA were not indicative of users' sensitivity to the matter. Instead, they mainly contained jokes about the negotiations. This was more evident in tweets that had received the largest number of "likes."

In the most popular tweet of this kind which received 3,476 "likes," user Massoud Saeedi, who pretended to be an Iranian government official wrote: "The text of the JCPOA had some problems we will not tell you about. We prepared a better text that you should not know about. However, we insisted on some conditions that we are not going to tell you about. Now an unidentified group of experts are reviewing the text, but we are not going to share with you the results of this review. You just need to know that we are better than the previous government."

The second most popular tweet observed that "The winner of the negotiations was the hotel that was the venue of the talks."

The report concluded that the reasons for the decline in sensitivity about the JCPOA include the extraordinarily prolonged duration of the talks and the attacks made on the deal during recent years by its Iranian and foreign opponents. Some Iranians may have concluded that the JCPOA may not be able to solve their problems.

US Should Designate Iran's Khamenei As A Terrorist - Former Envoy To UN

Aug 18, 2022, 14:15 GMT+1

Nikki Haley, the former American ambassador to the United Nations, has called for sanctions on Iran’s Supreme Leader, urging the Biden administration to designate him as a terrorist. 

Referring to ongoing nuclear talks with Iran, Haley said the US should, “not shake hands and do a deal with him” as he is “openly trying to execute Americans on our soil.”

She echoed similar remarks by advocacy group United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI), which called for designating Khamenei as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist under US Executive Order 13224 and other international terrorism authorities.

Underlining that Khamenei is the commander-in-chief of Iran’s Armed Forces, and the country’s Revolutionary Guard (IRGC) as well as directly in charge of Iran’s Supreme National Security Council, the UANI said since Khamenei became supreme leader, the Islamic Republic has “taken multiple foreign citizens hostage,” "ordered terrorist attacks.

UANI mentioned the bombings of Asociacion Mutual Israelita Argentina (AMIA) and Khobar Towers,” and "attempted mass casualty attacks in Europe where Americans were present,” referring to the failed bombing plot at a gathering of the Albania-based opposition group Mujahedin-e-Khalq Organization (MEK). 

The group also referred to plotted assassinations and attacks against current and former US and foreign officials, including former National Security Advisor John Bolton, former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, former Secretary of Defense Mark Esper, and former US Special Envoy for Iran Brian Hook, as well as inciting assassinations and abductions against US citizens and permanent residents, including author Salman Rushdie, and Iranian American dissident Masih Alinejad.

Workers Sentenced To Lashes, Imprisonment For Participating In Protest

Aug 18, 2022, 11:56 GMT+1

An Iranian company has started punishing its workers who participated in strikes and protests to demand their long-overdue salaries. 

Nearly 20 workers at Iran’s AzarAb Industries Construction company – which employs more than 2,500 people – were suspended from work for one year, and a local court sentenced them to 30 lashes, and three months imprisonment over their participation in a protest in late May. 

The workers of the company say their salaries have been paid regularly in the past two months but there is no stability in the managerial team and they keep changing. 

Iranian workers and pensioners have been holding regular nationwide protests during the past months to demand better work conditions and higher salaries on par with the increasing prices of essential foods and other commodities. 

On August 9, Iranian pensioners held another round of demonstrations in protest to the government’s decision to a 10-percent increase in payments while the inflation rate stands at 55 percent, denouncing the government's move to ignore decrees by the Supreme Labor Council, which had stipulated a 38-percent increase in the minimum wage.

Amid a dire economic situation in Iran that has been worsening in recent months, at least 10 workers have committed suicide in the last three months due to dismissal from their jobs and "livelihood problems".

With food prices rising faster after four years of United States’ ‘maximum pressure’ sanctions, Iranian workers and retirees have been holding regular protests or strikes to demand higher salaries. In June, Iran’s currency fell to a historic low of 333,000 rials to the US dollar.

Proposed Law Gives Clerics Control Over Iran’s Central Bank

Aug 18, 2022, 08:40 GMT+1
•
Maryam Sinaiee

Former officials of the Central Bank of Iran (CBI) have opposed a law that would give a clerical council control over the bank’s monetary and economic policies.

In a letter addressed to the speaker of the parliament, Mohammad-Bagher Ghalibaf, former officials pointed out that Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei has twice before “directly or indirectly” stopped the proposed legislation and asked Ghalibaf to remove it from the parliament’s agenda.

The signatories of the letter protested that a provision in the law would set up a clerical council within the central bank that would supersede all other decision-making mechanisms and in fact would set monetary policy. This they argued, would strip the bank of its ability to professionally execute its duties as the guardian of the national currency and protector of the country’s monetary stability.

The letter which was released to the media this week argued that the proposed legislation focuses on transformation of the central bank's structure and monetary policies and fails to offer any new solutions or initiatives that could satisfy high-ranking religious authorities’ and the people’s demand for the elimination of interest and resolving the problem of riba.

Riba, a concept meaning usury or charging unreasonably high-interest rates, is prohibited under Sharia law. Lending money, according to Sharia, should be a charitable act with no interest involved, rather than making profit for the bank that could lead to exploitation and loansharking.

However, this religious concept is incompatible with modern economic realities and bank interests are not only common in Iran but sometimes quite high.

“The purpose of [establishing] clerical councils in [banks in] all Islamic countries is supervising the execution of Islamic-type contracts and elimination of interest from financial and credit facilities, not setting monetary, financial, and economic policies and [dealing with the issues] of inflation and liquidity,” the letter to the parliament speaker said.

The letter was signed by over 130 former officials including former central bank governors Akbar Komijani, Mahmoud Bahmani, Valiollah Seif, Tahmasb Mazaheri, and Mohammad Hossein Adeli, spanning three decades, as well as former bank board members and executives of other state and private banks.

The former banking officials also suggested that the central bank be given 18 months to come up with its own solutions and propose any required legislation through the government.

In recent years the CBI has lost its professional independence, being forced by government to print money and create a huge money supply that has led to 54-percent inflation rate.

After the Islamic Revolution of 1979, the Iranian banking system was altered to accommodate Islamic laws, particularly the ban on interest. Since then, authorities have resorted to various solutions to justify paying and charging interest without being accused of riba.

One of the solutions that banking authorities and high-ranking clerics agreed on was to redefine the contract between the bank and the individual or company taking a loan to conform with the Islamic notion of Murabahah which means cost-plus financing as well as other similar contracts.

In Murabahah contracts, the two sides agree to the cost and markup of the loan, which in essence is interest coated with religious jargon.

Besides banks and finance and credit institutions, there are also Islamic non-profit granting funds in Iran called Gharzolhasaneh (no-interest charity) funds.

All Iranian banks charge interest that is approved by the Central Bank at least once a year in proportion to the inflation rate and demand high value collateral items such as real estate.