• العربية
  • فارسی
BrandBrand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo

Repression, Prison Have Left No Independent Media In Iran, Experts Say

Iran International Newsroom
Jun 16, 2023, 13:13 GMT+1Updated: 17:27 GMT+1
A number of newspapers at a kiosk in Tehran
A number of newspapers at a kiosk in Tehran

Grim commentaries this week marked the 21st anniversary of Etemad, one of the few reformist papers left in Iran, as dozens of journalists were jailed in recent months.

The daily's managing editor Elias Hazrati, its leading columnist Abbas Abdi and former government spokesman Ali Rabiei wrote their accounts of the difficult situation facing the media in the newspaper's anniversary edition.

Hazrati, a former reformist lawmaker, wrote that he launched the paper at the end of his parliamentary career as "a media outlet for the majority of Iranians." He added that during the past 21 years he kept his promise of giving voice to both the older and younger generations of Iranian journalists. 

Etemad has been banned several times since its launch and its journalists came under pressure by the authoritarian government particularly under conservative presidents. 

100%
Etemad daily managing editor Elias Hazrati

that the government presumes newspapers that reflect society's problems are portraying a disparaging image of the country. Statesmen in Iran do not know that problems will not be solved if they are not discussed by the media.

Etemad daily managing editor Elias Hazrati
Complaining about censorship and government pressure on the press, Abdi wrote

Abdi said: "Newspapers act like medical examination reports. If nobody pays attention to what they highlight, problems will lead to serious abnormal situations." He further complained that the Iranian government has never taken the newspapers seriously and this is part of the crisis of media in Iran. 

Abdi added: "The government constantly insists that newspapers should not publish "negative news" and "disparaging accounts." They don’t see that the people are living in the society and see for themselves what is going on.

100%
Reformist columnist Abbas Abdi

"The crisis of the media in Iran has roots in different narratives and the government's reliance on its own narrative. As long as the narratives rather than realities drive the government's policies, the media cannot have their true status," Abdi said.

According to Abdi, Etemad and a few other newspapers have refused to play the role of trumpets that voice the government's views and propaganda. The fact that this newspaper has survived for 21 years, so far is in itself a success. What makes this effort worthwhile is the daily's commitment to reflect the truth. 

Abdi was pointing out the fact that reformist newspapers in Iran are short-lived as governments have a pretty low threshold for tolerating criticism. At times, like 2001, tens of newspapers and other publications were closed down overnight without any explanation. At least one reformist newspaper, Mellat, was banned before the day it hit newsstands for the first time. 

However, Etemad and a few other relatively critical newspapers are not free of daily censorship and self-censorship, as their reporting has to somewhat accommodate the regime’s ideology and rhetoric. For example, they cannot criticize the Supreme Leader, who should be mentioned as “the esteemed Leader.”

100%
Former government spokesman Ali Rabiei

Meanwhile, in an article in Etemad, former government spokesman, Ali Rabiei wrote that what makes the media situation different in Iran is the negative impact “of arresting and imprisoning independent Iranian journalists." 

What Rabiei said also referred to the emigration of hundreds of Iranian journalists to other countries, including Britain and the United States where key foreign-based Iranian media operate from. 

Rabiei pointed out that the Iranian government does not allow independent media to be active in Iran and arrests and jails journalists working on investigative reporting. But the emigration of independent journalist has gradually turned into a security threat for the Iranian government.

Iranian officials on a daily basis complain about investigative reports by foreign-based media that disclose corruption and inefficiency in the government and among its officials. Nonetheless, as Rabiei observed, the government perceives even the existing toothless media as a threat. 

Most Viewed

Iran’s dams may have been built to support missile bases - NYT
1

Iran’s dams may have been built to support missile bases - NYT

2

US Army seeks 17 bunkers in Israel, Saudi, Lebanon amid Iran threats - report

3

UK PM warns Iran against attacks on journalists and military bases

4

Iran’s daily hardships find a voice in IRGC-linked media

5

Iranian girl's suspected honor killing raises questions over school's role

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

Spotlight

  • Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely, experts say
    ANALYSIS

    Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely, experts say

  • Iran's wartime rallies turn against officials, fuel political feuds

    Iran's wartime rallies turn against officials, fuel political feuds

  • How Thai clerics in Iran were recruited to attack Israeli embassy in Bangkok
    EXCLUSIVE

    How Thai clerics in Iran were recruited to attack Israeli embassy in Bangkok

  • Mapping aircraft losses from US-Israeli strikes on Tehran airport
    SPECIAL REPORT

    Mapping aircraft losses from US-Israeli strikes on Tehran airport

  • Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence
    ANALYSIS

    Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence

  • 'Our turn to play': Iran hardliners call for breaking US blockade

    'Our turn to play': Iran hardliners call for breaking US blockade

  • Head full of pellets: protester recalls ordeal on Iran holiday island
    EXCLUSIVE

    Head full of pellets: protester recalls ordeal on Iran holiday island